Collection: Fudge Pick n Mix

Fudge Pick n Mix – A Hand-Packed Assortment of Pure Decadence

There’s something utterly satisfying about building your own Fudge Pick n Mix — a box of sweet, crumbly joy, crafted entirely to your taste. At Duncan’s Online Sweet Shop, we’ve taken this simple pleasure and elevated it to a gourmet experience. No stale, factory-packed cubes here — just fresh, flavourful fudge, hand-packed on the day you order, made for moments that deserve a touch of indulgence.

A Personalised Box of Fudge Luxury

Whether you like your fudge silky smooth, delightfully crumbly, or boldly flavoured, our pick and mix system gives you the power to choose every square. Our extensive range features both timeless classics and creative new combinations — from old-school vanilla and chocolate swirl to bold innovations like Biscoff fudge, Jaffa Cake, mint choc chip, cookie dough, and caramel brownie. Each flavour is made with the care and quality you'd expect from a traditional British sweet shop — minus the dusty jars and lukewarm customer service.

Built for Sweet Lovers and Gift Givers Alike

This isn’t just about treating yourself — though we wholeheartedly encourage it. A personalised Fudge Pick n Mix makes a thoughtful gift for birthdays, thank-yous, anniversaries or ‘thinking of you’ moments. Want to really impress? Browse our full range of Fudge Selection Boxes for expertly packed assortments, or explore our beautifully wrapped Fudge Gift Boxes if you're after a little wow factor.

Freshly Packed to Order — Always

At Duncan’s, we don’t pre-pack. We don’t cut corners. We certainly don’t let good fudge sit around waiting to be eaten. Every order is hand-selected and packed fresh on the day, ensuring a just-made softness and richness that supermarket fudge simply can’t match. It’s what makes us the best place to buy fudge online — that, and the fact that our team are complete flavour obsessives who know exactly how to balance creamy, buttery, sweet and bold in every square.

Flavours for Every Palate

• Classic favourites: Vanilla, clotted cream, chocolate fudge, salted caramel
• Modern creations: Cookie dough, Biscoff, mint chocolate, Jaffa Cake
• Seasonal treats: Pumpkin spice, white chocolate raspberry, gingerbread
• Vegan options: We also offer dairy-free fudge to make sure everyone gets a taste

Fudge, Reimagined as Pick and Mix

We’ve taken everything people love about pick and mix — the freedom, the fun, the flavours — and applied it to fudge. Want three squares of cookie dough, five of chocolate orange and a chunk of lemon meringue? Done. Prefer to keep it classic with all-vanilla and salted caramel? That’s your call. There’s no right or wrong here — just a perfectly customised pouch, fresh from our fudge range to your door.

Why Our Customers Keep Coming Back

Because we do things properly. No bland supermarket boxes. No lazy mass production. Just expertly made fudge, freshly packed in small batches and dispatched with the kind of care you’d expect from a family-run sweet shop. And if you’re looking to scale up your indulgence, our Fudge Hampers bring even more flavour, beautifully presented and ready to gift.

So if you're after the finest Fudge Pick n Mix in the UK — bursting with flavour, packed fresh, and entirely your own creation — Duncan’s Online Sweet Shop is your sweetest destination.